This guy named Ben Palmer made an "Immigration tip line" and people call it thinking he's ICE.
-
This guy named Ben Palmer made an "Immigration tip line" and people call it thinking he's ICE.
He records them and shares it with the world.
What do people sound like when reporting their neighbors, coworkers, students? Are they confident they are doing a righteous good thing?
Witness the banality of evil in these sheepish suburban voices.
@futurebird she (the teacher in the video) does not sound very bright. as if she's just picked up this horrible idea somewhere and accepted it without examining it.
-
W wando@troet.cafe shared this topic
-
This guy named Ben Palmer made an "Immigration tip line" and people call it thinking he's ICE.
He records them and shares it with the world.
What do people sound like when reporting their neighbors, coworkers, students? Are they confident they are doing a righteous good thing?
Witness the banality of evil in these sheepish suburban voices.
der größte lump im ganzen land, das ist und bleibt der denunziant!
-
@PhilGopon @futurebird yeah, or substitute "slaves" and "plantation owners".
-
@futurebird well, that's probably how fasiscm worked in Germany and my country, Austria, some 80 years ago.
Humans can be that cruel.@mcnknopp @futurebird When I watch, read or hear about such atrocities, it is shocking, yet totally not surprising me.
That's why Hannah Arendt's concept of „The Banality of Evil“ still is one of the most disturbing, yet eye-opening works about exactly this.The British Academy: "Hannah Arendt's lessons for our times: the banality of evil, totalitarianism and statelessness" by Prof. Lyndsey Stonebridge:
https://www.thebritishacademy.ac.uk/blog/hannah-arendts-lessons-for-our-times-the-banality-of-evil-totalitarianism-and-statelessness/ -
What disturbs me is the total lack of urgency and confidence in these “reporters” as soon as Ben simply describes what they are doing “so you are reporting this person so they will be removed from the country” they put all of the responsibility on him (one caller says “isn’t that what we are doing?)
People scoff at insects following pheromone trails but the average ant puts more thought into her next action than some of these people. “The government says report these people better do it”
@futurebird Thank you for watching this and telling us.
-
This guy named Ben Palmer made an "Immigration tip line" and people call it thinking he's ICE.
He records them and shares it with the world.
What do people sound like when reporting their neighbors, coworkers, students? Are they confident they are doing a righteous good thing?
Witness the banality of evil in these sheepish suburban voices.
@myrmepropagandisti don't know if they're here illegally. i just think it's odd ..
that's chilling. but this is how fascism worked in germany, or the east-german rule. you need a lot of those inofficial snitches to rule, and you easily get them. -
This guy named Ben Palmer made an "Immigration tip line" and people call it thinking he's ICE.
He records them and shares it with the world.
What do people sound like when reporting their neighbors, coworkers, students? Are they confident they are doing a righteous good thing?
Witness the banality of evil in these sheepish suburban voices.
@GlasWolf @futurebird Glad he made it to expose the racist twats.
-
Is not like they call in, crying and in distress having been menaced by some horrible gang— no it’s a literal child trying their best to learn the damn alphabet— and this lady is like “oh he’s kinda different better call the government”
@futurebird I almost called the police once. I was anxious and wanted to visit a public park. There were people different than me playing soccer and hanging out. I had heard that some cars were broken into. I noticed a guy walk up to my car and look in the windows. He seemed to be looking in other cars. I think he clocked me and walked back to the group. I drove away. I thought about calling but:
* looking in cars is not a crime
* I was afraid, my judgement was cloudy
* I don't trust the police. -
@futurebird I almost called the police once. I was anxious and wanted to visit a public park. There were people different than me playing soccer and hanging out. I had heard that some cars were broken into. I noticed a guy walk up to my car and look in the windows. He seemed to be looking in other cars. I think he clocked me and walked back to the group. I drove away. I thought about calling but:
* looking in cars is not a crime
* I was afraid, my judgement was cloudy
* I don't trust the police.It’s probably a good call. If I see someone like that I try to ask someone “do you know who that is?” (eg. ask some of the checkers guys if it’s summer or maybe the postman in winter)
If I’m not intimidated by the person I say hello to them.
There much less risky was of being nebby— and in the US at least cops are not very helpful or effective at investigating crimes that impact regular people— they are happy to use any noise you make to justify their own ends.
-
This guy named Ben Palmer made an "Immigration tip line" and people call it thinking he's ICE.
He records them and shares it with the world.
What do people sound like when reporting their neighbors, coworkers, students? Are they confident they are doing a righteous good thing?
Witness the banality of evil in these sheepish suburban voices.
@futurebird @dannotdaniel Is there any chance that Ben Palmer is not actually representing what really happened but creating something for our consumption? Do you know him? Can you verify him in someway?
-
I listened to the first half of this, and the caller used school resources to look up the ethnicities of the child's parents so she could report them. Don't report any data to school!
@futurebird @richpuchalsky that jumped out at me too; like, on what form did the school ask for country of birth of the parents of students?!?
-
This guy named Ben Palmer made an "Immigration tip line" and people call it thinking he's ICE.
He records them and shares it with the world.
What do people sound like when reporting their neighbors, coworkers, students? Are they confident they are doing a righteous good thing?
Witness the banality of evil in these sheepish suburban voices.
@futurebird Thanks for sharing I was about to. THIS is the kind of people who turned in Anne Frank. They are right there LIVE.
-
Is not like they call in, crying and in distress having been menaced by some horrible gang— no it’s a literal child trying their best to learn the damn alphabet— and this lady is like “oh he’s kinda different better call the government”
@futurebird i feel I need to give this guy a hug though. What a task to have to not only listen to that, but even engage...
-
This guy named Ben Palmer made an "Immigration tip line" and people call it thinking he's ICE.
He records them and shares it with the world.
What do people sound like when reporting their neighbors, coworkers, students? Are they confident they are doing a righteous good thing?
Witness the banality of evil in these sheepish suburban voices.
@futurebird The casual assumption that the parents must be undocumented because they were born in other countries ... do these people not know about green cards? They talk about "doing it the right way" but don't even consider that someone with an accent might be here legally, that there is such a status as permanent legal resident. And they let someone this ignorant be a teacher
-
It’s probably a good call. If I see someone like that I try to ask someone “do you know who that is?” (eg. ask some of the checkers guys if it’s summer or maybe the postman in winter)
If I’m not intimidated by the person I say hello to them.
There much less risky was of being nebby— and in the US at least cops are not very helpful or effective at investigating crimes that impact regular people— they are happy to use any noise you make to justify their own ends.
@futurebird these are great suggestions of better solutions! Your analysis is spot on.
As a kid, we had police come to our summer camps with their dog to talk to us and tell us if we see something, say something for people acting suspicious in the neighborhood. Kids have to hear other adults explain to them the nuances, or they might blindly trust the "good cop" authority, and not recognize their own biases.
-
This guy named Ben Palmer made an "Immigration tip line" and people call it thinking he's ICE.
He records them and shares it with the world.
What do people sound like when reporting their neighbors, coworkers, students? Are they confident they are doing a righteous good thing?
Witness the banality of evil in these sheepish suburban voices.
This needs to be on the Colbert show or some national show.
-
IDK he didn't tell us who she was or put her address up there. That would be kind of irresponsible since people are mad.
That leaves anyone mad about this to try to think about if they know someone like her.
And to maybe reflect on if they might have done anything similar ever.
@futurebird It can do that. It is interesting to see something like this. And know what is out there.
But I worry it can "confirm" the bias that -some- leftists have that conservatives are heartless monsters, end of story.
-
This guy named Ben Palmer made an "Immigration tip line" and people call it thinking he's ICE.
He records them and shares it with the world.
What do people sound like when reporting their neighbors, coworkers, students? Are they confident they are doing a righteous good thing?
Witness the banality of evil in these sheepish suburban voices.
@futurebird "Der größte Lump im ganzen Land,
das ist und bleibt der Denunziant." -
@futurebird It can do that. It is interesting to see something like this. And know what is out there.
But I worry it can "confirm" the bias that -some- leftists have that conservatives are heartless monsters, end of story.
@Scofisticated @futurebird racists *are* heartless monsters towards the people they are racist against. That’s how in-group vs out-group works (and why ethnic cleansing is always preceded by an uptick in dehumanizing language). Empathy only extends to the in-group, and they are probably kind enough to not be a monster. Perhaps we can hope that in-group can be expanded, but in my experience people tend to cling tightly to whatever in-group they were brought up in, unless they are neurodivergent.
-
@Scofisticated @futurebird racists *are* heartless monsters towards the people they are racist against. That’s how in-group vs out-group works (and why ethnic cleansing is always preceded by an uptick in dehumanizing language). Empathy only extends to the in-group, and they are probably kind enough to not be a monster. Perhaps we can hope that in-group can be expanded, but in my experience people tend to cling tightly to whatever in-group they were brought up in, unless they are neurodivergent.
@Frantasaur @futurebird I believe saying people are heartless is also dehumanizing. Whether or not they will change is another matter. But, assuming they cant is robbing them of the possibility and opportunity.
