I am getting frothy at all this AI hate.
-
I am getting frothy at all this AI hate. Especially where it comes to music. A good song is a good song, if creativity has been used to create it, adn an AI tool has been used to save thousands on production that most of us don't have, what the hell is the problem? Purists and elitism makes me wild! I don't make a living from my music, but if someone has the brains and the drive to do that, why in heck not!
-
I am getting frothy at all this AI hate. Especially where it comes to music. A good song is a good song, if creativity has been used to create it, adn an AI tool has been used to save thousands on production that most of us don't have, what the hell is the problem? Purists and elitism makes me wild! I don't make a living from my music, but if someone has the brains and the drive to do that, why in heck not!
@lulu_bear I totally feel you. There have actually been some really, really great stuff come from a combination of people's creativity and services like suno, and I see absolutely nothing wrong with it. All the songs I've create have been my own lyrics and suno's magical musical abilities combined, and do actually make that stuff happen, going into a studio, hiring a band, recording the tracks, would cost me thousands of dollars over what my husband and I make in a month. The AI hatred really does make me sad.
-
@lulu_bear I totally feel you. There have actually been some really, really great stuff come from a combination of people's creativity and services like suno, and I see absolutely nothing wrong with it. All the songs I've create have been my own lyrics and suno's magical musical abilities combined, and do actually make that stuff happen, going into a studio, hiring a band, recording the tracks, would cost me thousands of dollars over what my husband and I make in a month. The AI hatred really does make me sad.
@cary5871 @lulu_bear even though I am an experienced musician now for 36 years, I agree with every sentiment of what is being said here. It does not offend me, and I do not have a problem with it in any way. If there is a tool that allows someone to be creative, let them be creative.
-
@cary5871 @lulu_bear even though I am an experienced musician now for 36 years, I agree with every sentiment of what is being said here. It does not offend me, and I do not have a problem with it in any way. If there is a tool that allows someone to be creative, let them be creative.
@darren_duff @cary5871 @lulu_bear agreed. It beats having to either buy synthetic instruments and a keyboard, or having to hire a band and get studio time. I wouldn't do it personally because I don't like the quality myself, but it works for many.
-
@darren_duff @cary5871 @lulu_bear agreed. It beats having to either buy synthetic instruments and a keyboard, or having to hire a band and get studio time. I wouldn't do it personally because I don't like the quality myself, but it works for many.
@SapphireRose91 @darren_duff @cary5871 @lulu_bear I think AI music usage falls into a few different camps.
1. The people that give a random prompt, hit generate and say 'I wrote a thing.' No. No you did not.2. The people that spend time crafting lyrics and sculpting the AI the way they want, and get amazing results just the way they imagined.
3. The other group of people (me included) who feed it my own music and get it to remix/reboot/reimagine whatever you want to call it, my music in entirely different ways.
Sometimes I'll then take that back to Logic and replay the bits I like and change the bits I don't.AI in the case of numbers 2 and 3 is a tool then, not a 'be all and end all' bandaid. It should not be that.
The people that hate AI hate it because all the number oners break it for the rest of us, those who care about what we're doing, our craft, our joy, and our care and attention to detail.
That, at least, is my take on it.
Happy to be told otherwise. -
S svenja@mstdn.games shared this topic
